BlueChew vs Hims: price per dose and what you get

BlueChew and Hims cost about the same per dose of sildenafil, but they sell different things: BlueChew sells only compounded tablets that dissolve in the mouth, none of them FDA-approved, while Hims sells FDA-approved generic sildenafil and tadalafil, brand-name Viagra and Cialis, and its own compounded chews. As of October 2026, BlueChew’s sildenafil tablet started at $3.53 and Hims’s generic sildenafil at $4 per use.

The prices below come from each company’s own pages, and we compare them on price per dose, what is FDA-approved, care, billing and what the FDA has said about each.

BlueChew vs Hims at a glance

BlueChew’s prices are as of October 2026 and were re-read on Oct 27, 2026; Hims’s are as of October 2026. Hims shows starting prices and says the final price depends on the product and plan.

Price per dose

This is the comparison most people want. Starting prices for one dose:

On sildenafil, BlueChew is 47 cents a dose cheaper at the starting price; on as-needed tadalafil, $1.53 cheaper. Both companies say the price changes with strength and how many doses you buy, so the gap at your dose may differ. For context, FDA-approved generic sildenafil cost $1.60 to $6.25 a dose at the online providers we checked in October 2026, so neither is the cheapest per dose.

The strengths aren’t like for like. BlueChew’s pages show 45 mg for SIL and 9 mg for TAD, strengths that don’t exist as FDA-approved tablets, and they’re absorbed under the tongue. FDA-approved generic tablets come in the label strengths: 25, 50 and 100 mg of sildenafil, and 2.5, 5, 10 and 20 mg of tadalafil.

Compounded vs FDA-approved

This is the bigger difference between the two.

BlueChew sells only compounded products. A compounding pharmacy prepares each tablet for your prescription, and none is FDA-approved; they are not Viagra, Cialis or Levitra and not generics of them. The FDA doesn’t review compounded drugs for safety, effectiveness or quality, and they weren’t part of the trials behind the approved tablets. BlueChew’s GOLD tablet goes further, mixing sildenafil, tadalafil, apomorphine and oxytocin; see BlueChew GOLD.

Hims sells mostly FDA-approved tablets. Its generic sildenafil and tadalafil contain the same drugs as Viagra and Cialis, and the FDA requires a generic to deliver the same amount of drug to the body as the brand. It also sells brand-name Viagra and Cialis. Its sildenafil and tadalafil chews are compounded and aren’t FDA-approved, so check which one you are ordering.

If you want the version that was tested in trials, the approved tablet is the one. In trials of Viagra, 63% to 82% of men on 25 to 100 mg reported improved erections, against 24% on placebo, according to the Viagra label.

Daily tadalafil and brand names

Hims sells daily tadalafil from $40 a month. That’s a low dose (2.5 or 5 mg on the Cialis label) taken every day so you don’t have to time a pill around sex. BlueChew’s TAD tablet is prescribed for as-needed use, and it doesn’t offer a daily plan. Hims also sells brand-name Viagra at $139 per use and daily Cialis at $958 a month, for people who want the brand; BlueChew doesn’t sell brand names.

Care and billing

BlueChew: a licensed provider from one of five provider-owned medical groups reviews your profile, usually within 24 hours, and approved orders ship within 24 hours. Its pages don’t describe scheduled follow-ups. You can switch drugs from your account. Plans renew automatically and each cycle covers medication, shipping and tax. It takes no returns on prescription products, and you cancel with Put On Hold or by email at least 24 hours before renewal; its terms say 48 hours. It serves every state except North Dakota.

Hims: a licensed provider reviews your online assessment, and the subscription includes periodic check-ins, unlimited messaging, free shipping and an app to manage your plan. Its terms say subscriptions renew unless you cancel at least 2 days before renewal, and it doesn’t refund partly used periods, though it may refund case by case. It doesn’t bill insurance.

Neither charges a separate membership fee for ED treatment.

What the FDA said to each

On Sept 9, 2025, the FDA sent warning letters to both companies, among others that day.

• The BlueChew letter quoted four claims about its compounded sildenafil and tadalafil, including “SIL: Same active as Viagra,” and said they implied its products were the same as FDA-approved drugs.
• The Hims letter was about two claims for its compounded semaglutide, a weight-loss drug, one of which compared it with Ozempic and Wegovy. It wasn’t about its ED products.

A warning letter is a formal notice, not a fine or a recall. See our BlueChew review and is Hims legit for more.

Reviews

On Oct 27, 2026, Trustpilot showed BlueChew at 4.1 out of 5 from 3,264 reviews (66% five-star, 17% one-star) and Hims at 2.9 from 9,667 reviews (38% five-star, 29% one-star). Hims’s profile covers all its categories, including weight loss and hair loss, not only ED. Trustpilot says it doesn’t fact-check reviews.

Which one fits

• Choose BlueChew if you can’t or won’t swallow a pill and accept a compounded, unapproved product. Its single-drug tablets start a little cheaper per dose than Hims’s generics.
• Choose Hims if you want an FDA-approved tablet, daily tadalafil, brand-name Viagra or Cialis, or ongoing check-ins and messaging.
• Choose neither if price per dose matters most: other providers sell FDA-approved generic sildenafil for less. Among providers we list, MyDrHank sells generic sildenafil from $25 a month and generic tadalafil from $30 a month, as of October 2026.

Other options

Our best online ED providers list ranks the providers we list on price per dose, care, options, transparency and experience. For one drug, see the sildenafil and daily tadalafil lists. For how the drugs compare, read sildenafil vs tadalafil and the cheapest generic sildenafil online.