MyDrHank vs DudeMeds for ED
MyDrHank and DudeMeds for ED, side by side: what each charges, which treatments each prescribes, and the terms behind the price.
By the RxLineup editorial team · Fact-checked against provider sites and FDA labels · Updated
Only providers that pay us appear in our rankings and reviews, and we’re paid when you sign up through our links. How we make money
Higher score
MyDrHank
Rated 8.2 out of 10, Very good
From $25/mo
Sildenafil $25/mo
DudeMeds
Rated 6.7 out of 10, Fair
Price not published
Compounded ED chewables offered; price not published
The verdict
Only MyDrHank offers FDA-approved sildenafil and tadalafil (DudeMeds sells compounded ED chewables instead). Only DudeMeds offers compounded ED chewables. MyDrHank scores higher overall (8.2 vs 6.7), with its widest lead on price and value (8.3 vs 6.0).
Choose MyDrHank if…
You want FDA-approved sildenafil or tadalafil and a better price-and-value score (8.3 vs 6.0).
Choose DudeMeds if…
You want the option of compounded ED chewables.
What’s different
The three places where MyDrHank and DudeMeds differ for ED, from the prices and terms each publishes.
| Difference | MyDrHank | DudeMeds |
|---|---|---|
| Sildenafil | $25/mo | Compounded version only |
| Tadalafil | $30/mo | Compounded version only |
| Compounded ED chewables | Not offered | Offered; price not published |
Head to head
| Feature | MyDrHank review | DudeMeds review |
|---|---|---|
| Overall score | 8.2/10 Higher | 6.7/10 |
| Price | $25/mo | – |
| Sildenafil | $25/mo | Compounded version only |
| Daily tadalafil | $35/mo | Compounded version only |
| Treatments | Sildenafil, Tadalafil, Daily tadalafil | Compounded ED medication |
| Membership | None | – |
| Insurance | Self-pay | Self-pay |
| Refunds | No refund policy published | No refund once medication is dispensed |
| Next step | Visit MyDrHank for MyDrHank (opens in a new tab) | Visit DudeMeds for DudeMeds (opens in a new tab) |
– Not published by the provider.
Scores compared
Both providers are scored out of 10 on the same five weighted criteria. How we rate
MyDrHankDudeMeds
-
Price & value 30%
-
Clinical care 25%
-
Medication options 20%
-
Transparency 15%
-
Experience 10%
MyDrHank pros and cons
Strengths
- Sildenafil from $25 a month, daily tadalafil from $35
- Free consultation and free delivery
- Check-ins, dose adjustments and unlimited messaging
- Displays LegitScript certification
Drawbacks
- Prices are “from” figures; the strength and tablet count aren’t stated
- Calls its tablets generic, but its pages also say medication ships from a compounding pharmacy
- No refund policy published
- No state list published
DudeMeds pros and cons
Strengths
- Tablets that dissolve under the tongue
- Testosterone and hair treatments from the same provider
- Pause or cancel in your account
- Displays LegitScript certification
Drawbacks
- Prices show only after you accept its terms and telehealth consent
- Only compounded products, not FDA-approved
- No standard generic sildenafil or tadalafil tablets
- ED medications can’t ship to South Dakota
- No refund once medication is dispensed
Compare every ED provider side by side
See every ED provider’s score, monthly price and fine print on one page, ordered by our published rating method.